Has Airbnb lost its appeal? The numbers seem to say otherwise.

(That’s a tweet of a screenshot of a Fb put up, as a result of that is the world we dwell in.)

My recent story about Airbnb hosts getting sick of Airbnb made its personal little splash, based mostly on the variety of emails I obtained in response. And anti-Airbnb sentiment has bubbled up in all places, from Reddit to the Wall Avenue Journal.

But the so-called #Airbnbust, like most social media phenomena, appears to inaccurately mirror what’s really occurring in the true world. Whole demand for short-term leases really rose 24% in September in contrast with the identical month final yr, in response to a latest report by AirDNA, a trip rental knowledge platform. Common every day charges rose a staggering 31.9% in contrast with 2019.

So, based mostly on social media, everyone seems to be fed up with Airbnb. Primarily based on what’s occurring in the true world, Airbnb is doing higher than ever. What offers?

See: When is a hotel better than an Airbnb?

The Apple impact

Bear in mind Apple’s “Batterygate” scandal? Again in 2017 (roughly 5,000 years in the past), the corporate was accused of “deliberate obsolescence” with software program updates for its iPhones. Principally, Apple
AAPL,
+4.86%
was sued for deliberately slowing down its older telephones in an effort to get extra prospects to improve to newer fashions.

Social media was full of vitriolic backlash on the time, with iPhone customers proclaiming that they might change to Android units in droves. Did that occur? Nicely, Apple was a $671 billion firm in 2017 and has more than tripled in value to $2.5 trillion since. So, um, no.

The issue for Apple customers and Airbnb friends is that, whereas they won’t like every part these firms are doing, they just like the options even much less.

Switching to Android means studying a brand new interface and turning into a presumably dreaded inexperienced bubble on iMessage. And switching from Airbnb means both going “again” to inns, which have their very own drawbacks, or utilizing Airbnb’s competitors, which aren’t a lot better.

Somebody making an attempt to e book a home with mates in Palm Springs or backpack by South America on a shoestring remains to be more likely to flip to Airbnb. There merely aren’t many good options.

At the very least, not but.

Additionally see: The best and worst days to fly this December

Hostel takeover?

I chatted with Lee Gonzalez, who, along with her sister Lauren, is making an attempt one thing daring: Constructing hostels in America. Their firm, L&L hospitality, opened a brand new hostel in New York Metropolis in 2014, and one other in Portland, Oregon, in 2021. She says they struggled with the phrase “hostel” early on, however have since come to embrace it.

“Many vacationers categorically reject hostels within the U.S. — they consider the YMCA,” Gonzalez says. “In the long run, we just like the phrase. We would like individuals to come back with that hostel perspective.”

Their Portland property — referred to as Lolo Cross — bucks the stereotypical hostel picture of dirty dorms with a good grimier man noodling on guitar within the frequent room (at the least, that’s my picture). The rooms at Loss Cross are minimal however trendy. And the emphasis is on connecting friends with one another and the encircling space.

“We make certain our programming is plugged into the neighborhood,” she explains. “The areas are simply as a lot for the neighborhood as for the friends.”

Once I requested why her hostels may snatch a few of Airbnb’s market share, Gonzalez gave me a laundry record of causes. Her properties are inexpensive, clear (however no cleaning fees!) and run by skilled, on-site hosts. Even little issues, like having the ability to depart your baggage after check-out, make hostels extra handy than Airbnbs.

The most important hurdle, as talked about, is getting over North People’ aversion to the thought of hostels. But Gonzalez believes that Airbnb has itself set the stage for this transition, particularly amongst youthful vacationers.

“I’ve realized that Airbnb has really paved the way in which for hostels to work within the U.S. by introducing the thought of shared areas,” she explains. “As a result of Gen Z was raised with Airbnb, they don’t have the preconceived notions about hostels that older individuals do.”

Don’t miss: ‘This is one of the coolest places I’ve ever seen’: Splurge on a stayover — or at least a cocktail, during a layover — at this nostalgic airport hotel

Aggressive alternatives

Hostels solely problem a part of Airbnb’s enterprise mannequin — the half that draws low-frills vacationers on the lookout for a cheaper alternative to hotels. And legacy resort manufacturers aren’t able to go down and not using a struggle. Hilton inns lately aired a industrial squarely geared toward disgruntled Airbnbers, that includes a creepy trip rental stuffed with speaking dolls, whereas extolling the dependable virtues of an old school resort room.

And perhaps Airbnb wants some disruption of its personal. After turning all the journey business on its head after launching 15 years in the past, the holiday rental behemoth is not the younger upstart. Perhaps a brand new mannequin is able to emerge. What occurs subsequent relies on what we — the paying friends — determine to do.

Extra From NerdWallet

Sam Kemmis writes for NerdWallet. E mail: skemmis@nerdwallet.com. Twitter: @samsambutdif.