Icelandair is the primary airline to vow carbon-free flying on its home routes. That’s much less promising than it sounds. Guilt-free air journey has but to attain lift-off — though excessive oil and ticket costs could assist a bit.
Icelandair plans to make use of renewable power in battery-powered plane by 2030,. That is good, as far as it goes. However low-energy density batteries are heavy for the power they carry. So the airline is tapping right into a know-how that’s solely actually a possible answer for very short-haul flights.
That may be a downside in an business during which two-thirds of emissions come from journeys which might be longer than 1800km, in keeping with a Mission Attainable Partnership report on aviation. Total demand is about to develop steeply. Already, premium leisure journey has returned to pre-Covid ranges, in keeping with British Airways guardian IAG. Enterprise journeys usually are not far behind.
Frankly, there isn’t a know-how that may, by itself, ship guilt-free air journey. Making planes sleeker and extra environment friendly is a good begin — and saves cash — however can not get us to “web zero”. Subsequent up are biofuels — chemically much like jet gasoline however produced from waste. At this time, they account for 0.01% of aeroplane fuels, and are between 2 and 4 occasions dearer in keeping with BNEF, a consultancy. Worse, provide is restricted: solely a lot cooking oil exists with which to make inexperienced kerosene.
For unconstrained provide, we have to flip to renewable energy. Storing it as hydrogen, quite than in batteries, trades the load downside for one among house. Even supercooled to a liquid, hydrogen holds simply over 1 / 4 of the power as the identical quantity of petrol. Mixing hydrogen with CO₂ to create e-fuels types out each weight and house. However because the world strikes in the direction of web zero emissions, the CO₂ will must be sucked out of the air — an power intensive and costly course of.
The excellent news is that greater oil costs will assist give this ponderous downside some raise. They’ll make newer, power environment friendly plane extra engaging, and cut back the inexperienced premium for renewable applied sciences. In the meantime, gasoline prices account for roughly 1 / 4 of these costly airline tickets. That signifies that an business dedication to mix in 10% biofuels — say — would nonetheless solely add £6 to the price of a £100 ticket.
We aren’t fairly accomplished with flygskam — a Swedish phrase which means “flight disgrace”. However £6 is likely to be an inexpensive sum to assist assuage our consciences.
If you’re a subscriber and wish to obtain alerts when Lex articles are revealed, simply click on the button “Add to myFT”, which seems on the high of this web page above the headline.